A credit-rating upgrade is good news about a borrower. For a bond buyer, however, the outcome also depends on the purchase price. If the market anticipated the improvement, much of the benefit may already have gone to earlier investors.

In its 17 November Caucasus and Central Asia report, ING argues that market valuations have moved ahead of official ratings. That is an analytical assessment, not a new rating-agency decision.

One payment, three purchase prices

Imagine a bond paying an annual coupon of 6 currency units. Bought at 100, it has a current yield of 6%. At 105, the same coupon produces approximately 5.71%. At 95, it produces approximately 6.32%.

Bond price and current yield
FinFly illustration: annual coupon 6. Current yield, not yield to maturity.

Current yield is the coupon divided by the purchase price. It excludes the redemption outcome, reinvestment, taxes and fees. A fuller assessment requires yield to maturity and the terms of the individual security.

FactorWhat it affects
Credit riskThe probability of obligations being met
Market interest ratesThe price of existing bonds
Time to maturitySensitivity to interest-rate changes
The investor’s spending currencyThe result after currency conversion

Why reliability and profit are different

Even a more reliable borrower's bond can fall in price. New bonds might offer higher coupons, making an existing security less attractive at its previous price. The issuer's ability to pay has not necessarily deteriorated.

Liquidity matters too. A quoted value in an app may differ from the price available for a quick sale of a large holding. Comparing rating letters alone is therefore insufficient.

What an upgrade announcement leaves unanswered

Separate three developments: the agency's decision, the bond's price movement and the change in its yield. Then examine how much of the expected improvement the price already reflects. A rating describes creditworthiness; an investor's return comes from specific cash flows and the price paid for them.